Saturday, February 9th, 2008...6:55 pm
Backpacker Magazine 2008 Gear Guide Lists A Whopping 480 Bags
That number — 480 — is a bit overwhelming at first glance. But if you apply my 1-15 rule (your bag should not be over 1 pound, 15 ounces), you trim the choices to 129 sleeping bags.
To help pair this list down further, you need to consider temperature rating.
I own a Western Mountaineering Highlite, a 16 ounce, 38-degree bag. Inside the protection of a tent with a jacket, thermal bottoms and socks, I can get that bag down to a 20-25 degree rating. And my bag gets me through three seasons pretty nicely.
Honestly, there have been a few nights when I wished I had something a bit warmer, but I was only “chilly” at worst. You need to ask yourself if you really need a 20 or 30 degree rated bag, 0r if a higher rated, lighter model will do.
You’ve got to balance lightness versus comfort (and safety). There’s nothing worse than a cold, restless night on the trail. If you’re a warm sleeper you can probably get by on a higher temperated rate bag. If you get cold easily, then go for a lower rated bag.
Backpacker Magazine listed 45 bags with a temperature ratings of 30 degrees or less that meet the 1-15 rule. Only 13 bags on this list are rated at 20 degrees or below and still 1 pound, 15 ounces or less. Four of those are made by one company: Nunatak Gear LLC. The quest for lightness often comes with a hefty price tag as well with the 20-degree rated “Alpinist Nunatak” selling for $384.
Because bags are so well made and so light these days by comparison with just five years ago when I purchased my Highlite, I think I might consider a 20-degree bag for seven or eight extra ounces.
Be light. Be safe. Be one with the pack.





3 Comments
March 3rd, 2008 at 1:57 pm
[...] presents Backpacker Magazine 2008 Gear Guide Lists A Whopping 480 Bags posted at LightBackpacking.com while we are on the subject of gear, Bruce has narrowed Backpacker [...]
April 23rd, 2008 at 10:19 am
Wow, 480 was a little overwhelming. But what you wrote helps a lot. Any ideas for packing kids in the backcountry? We need to update our gear.
December 28th, 2008 at 4:01 pm
Interesting article, and I would have never thought there were this many choices in sleeping bags! Even 129 is almost overwhelming. I can’t emphasis enough that the balance between lightness verses comfort in a sleeping bag is so important!
Leave a Reply